Now converted into flats

St. Matthew's Vicarage
Richard Thornburgh
Rev. William T McCormack - the first Vicar

St. Matthew’s Church used to stand on the corner of Sutherland Road and College Terrace, Kemp Town. In 1878, the Vicar of St. George’s church, Rev. J. H. Rogers, recognised that since St. George’s was chiefly attended by the rich and well-off, the poorer families who lived on the northern edge of its district lacked any church building within easy reach.  He therefore began the process of constructing a “tin chapel”.

Mr. W. Percival Boxall, J.P. of Belle Vue Hall, Eastern Road, offered a piece of land in Sutherland Road valued at £1,300 for the site of this new enterprise, but for some reason Rogers was prevented by the Diocese from accepting this gift. Boxall donated £1,000 in cash to the Chichester Diocesan Association instead, who then transferred the sum to St. George’s accounts, from which Rogers was permitted to pay Boxall for the land, making up the difference of £300 from the Church’s own funds.

A corrugated iron church
On January 15th, 1879, a corrugated iron church dedicated to St. Matthew was opened on the site with one of St. George’s curates in charge. At the same time schoolrooms were constructed, also in corrugated iron, both buildings being preliminary to a single permanent structure, the plan being to house the Infant school in the church’s basement. In consultation with the Archdeacon, the neighbourhood surrounding St. Matthew’s had been marked out into districts, and since then each district had been assigned a District Visitor, a Scripture Reader, and the services of a District Nurse. A very large sum was already subscribed towards the Building Fund, and an Endowment Fund had been started to provide future income.

An improvement in the condition of the neighbourhood
Throughout the following year the congregation of St. George’s gave generously for the new project, the first collection on January 18th 1880 amounting to £21 8s 11d. The Iron Church had now been open twelve months and the congregations were encouraging. The Day school was attended by more than 190 children, and the Sunday schools regularly drew over 260 to the various classes. Rogers could also perceive that there was “a very decided improvement in the moral and social condition of the neighbourhood.”

A Temperance Association formed
On March 29th, 1880, the “St. George’s & St. Matthew’s Church of England Temperance Association” was formed, with branches for both adults and juveniles. In the first year seventy-two men joined the Adult Society, of which, after twelve months, sixty-two remained as members, fifty-one of whom were total abstainers. Of the ten who had left, two had broken the pledge and gone back to excessive drinking, which should not be seen as particularly surprising in a town which boasted almost the highest proportion of churches and public houses to the percentage of the population in the whole of England. One of the practical results of the establishment of this Association was the founding of an allied “Working Men’s Temperance Association” which regularly met in a new Coffee & Reading Room especially opened in Sutherland Road.

New buildings threaten the  iron church
Throughout 1880 new houses had been springing up around St. Matthew’s on all sides, and the Town Council informed Rogers that because of this rapid expansion and the general ambience of the area, the iron church and schoolroom would have to be replaced by permanent structures in the space of little more than two years. Plans were therefore drawn up for the new church, and Spring 1881 set as the starting date for construction.

A new St Matthew’s emerges
The St. Matthew’s Building Committee arranged that the new church should be built in sections, taking up a contract in the first instance for £4,000, towards which they had in cash and promises the sum of £2,000. This later increased to £3,600, with the Endowment Fund for the future guaranteed income of the Church reaching £1,025. The architect entrusted with the work was Mr. John Norton of Old Bond Street, London, and the first part of the contract was completed by the close of the year.

A stone cross shatters in a thunderstorm
By late 1883 the work on the body of St. Matthew’s was finished, at a cost of £13,000, and the building, still with part of the tower and all of the steeple yet to be constructed, was consecrated in September. A few days later a severe thunderstorm broke out over the district, and with the contractors not yet having fixed the lightning conductors, one of the five feet high stone crosses on the roof just over the chancel, was struck and shattered to pieces. The cross was soon replaced and the earthing bands hurriedly put in place. Rev. William Thomas McCormack, up until then a Curate at St. George’s, was the first Incumbent of St. Matthew’s.

£1,000 was donated towards the building of St. Matthew’s Parsonage, a gift that was matched by the Ecclesiastical Commissioners, all the money being spent on the construction of 1, College Terrace, a house still standing today but now converted into flats.

The end of an era for St Matthew’s
In less than one hundred years yet another round of parish reorganisation decided that St. Matthew’s had outlived its usefulness, and it was declared redundant, de-consecrated, and demolished around the close of the 1960’s, its dedication only living on in the name given to the small block of flats erected on the site, “St. Matthew’s Court.” It is a matter of speculation how many of the inhabitants know from where their address originated, or anything about the former history of their homes.

Comments about this page

  • I was a pupil at Brighton College, I was in Tim Pearce’s English Class. The church had been demolished and the remains were being burnt. Blackened wood, smoke and rubble! Our class went for a walk to observe all this and write an essay entitled ‘The Burning Church’.

    By Bernard Dutton-Briant (04/09/2005)
  • Wonderful to come across the picture of my great grandfather on my mother’s side – Rev. William Thomas McCormick. It is also indicative of the reason one delves into family history – he is the spitting image of my brother- just shows how history repeats itself (it never grows old, even if we do). I spent a short time in Brighton some years ago and went to the site of the old church; even called into the shop next door and had a wonderful chat to the proprietress – she was very helpful. I will be back. Thank you to those of Brighton and beyond with the interest to keep ‘life alive’.

    By Warwick Charles Bourke (12/09/2005)
  • I am interested to make contact with Bernard Dutton-Briant as we may be distantly related. Thank you. Email:

    By Jan Jozsa (Ferntree Gully, Australia) (06/11/2005)
  • My grandfather, Rev William John Taylor, was the Vicar at St. Matthews from 1951 to the mid 1960s when he retired. We lived at St. Matthew’s Vicarage next door at 1 College Terrace in 1948 before moving to London. I am now retired and living in Toronto Canada.

    By Simon Black (02/07/2006)
  • I am about to move into the top floor flat and it’s nice to see some history attached to the building.

    By Cat Messer (26/01/2007)
  • I am the brother of Warwick Bourke (see comment posted on 12/9/2005) and also of course the great grandson of the vicar: Rev William McCormick.  I would like to contact Bernard Dutton-Briant, Simon Black and Cat Messer re St Mathews and College Terrace.

    By Bryson Bourke (17/10/2008)
  • I was in the church choir at St Mathew’s in the early fifties and remember the Rev. Taylor very well. I seem to remember him living in Belvue Gardens but may be mistaken. The choirmaster was a Mr Cook? who lived in Patcham. I also attended Sunday School at the Vicarage next to the Church in College Street and can remember us all huddled around the gas fire on cold winter afternoons.

    By Dave Hamblin (15/03/2012)
  • Mr. Hamblin is correct – Rev. Taylor did live in Belle Vue Gardens, at No.7. When I was very ill with appendicitis in the summer of 1956, aged 3, my parents went and asked him to pray with them for me. Clearly I survived!

    By Richard Thornburgh (30/08/2013)
  • Dear mum, Gladys Agar 93, passed away last month and trying to discover the church that mum and dad married in, in 1943. We discovered ,while going through old momentos, photos and press cuttings, that in fact it was St Matthews church, Queens Park, where they were married. Sad to discover that the building was demolished in the 60’s but still, a historic place for the ‘Agar’ family.

    By Steven Agar (28/11/2017)
  • My great grandfather George Waller, married my great grandmother in this church early in the 1900s. He was the son of a plasterer, that my father still recalls being told about, by his grandfather (as above) as they were the plaster mouldings I understand were called “roses”. I believe George’s father had a business in Kemp Town, and although it has been many years since I walked around Kemp Town to visit the site of the Waller business, the church, Queens Park and Hendon Street, I still remember how much I later learned, the south side of Eastern road was radically changed, as I have one of the Brighton books which shows maps of the area.

    By Mark David Wells (08/07/2018)
  • I was christened in St Matthews Church on 30 September 1962 by Revd W J Taylor.

    By Carol Hyatt (16/08/2020)

Add a comment about this page

Your email address will not be published.